UK Man Loses Bid to Recover Over $700 Million Worth of Bitcoin

James Howells has lost a bid to recover $731 million worth of Bitcoin from a landfill. He tried to sue the local council of Newport in the UK to gain access to the landfill or receive $605 million in compensation.
Judge Throws Out Bid
A UK judge ruled against Howells, after he sued Newport council to gain access to a landfill that he believes contains a hard drive with Bitcoin now valued at around $731 million. Howells argued that a former partner of his mistakenly threw out his hard drive containing the Bitcoin back in 2013. The complainant wanted access to the site to recover his hard drive.
However, the Newport Council asked the judge to strike out his legal action to access the landfill. High Court Judge Keyser KC stated the complainant had not established reasonable grounds for the claim. He added that their claim stood no realistic prospect of success at a full trial.
Howells Reacts To The Ruling
After the ruling, Howells said he was “very upset.” He added that the case being thrown out at the earliest stage did not provide him with a chance to get justice. Howells stated that much more could have been explained at a full trial.
According to Howells, he had been attempting to engage the Newport City Council for the last 12 years. According to him, the latest ruling felt like a “kick in the teeth.” Howells added that his decision was not about greed, and he was willing to share the proceeds. However, no one in power would have a conversation with him.
The claimant added that the ruling had taken everything from him, and it was the “great British injustice system” that had struck once more.
Details Of The Hearing
The hearing took place in December 2024, and the court heard how Howells had been one of the early adopters of Bitcoin. As the value of the missing wallet soared, he hired a team of experts to attempt to find it.
He had asked the council for permission numerous times for access to the site, and had offered to split the proceeds if he succeeded. Howells mined the Bitcoin in 2009 back when mining was cheap. However, he forgot about the coins, when he threw away the hard drive.
However, James Groudie KC, representing the council, argued that the current laws meant the hard drive was now the landfill’s property. Additionally, existing environmental permits forbade attempts to excavate the site to look for a hard drive.
According to Goudie, Howells’s offer to donate 10% of the proceeds to the community was encouraging the council to break the rules for a share of the coins.
Details Of The Site
The landfill in question has over 1.4 million tons of waste. However, Howells stated that he had narrowed down the possible location to a site holding 100,000 tons of waste. According to Howells, the Bitcoin in the hard drive could be worth over $1.2 billion by 2025.
Conclusion
Howells' case is not the first time that someone has lost access to a valuable cache of Bitcoin; a few years back, Stefan Thomas lost access to an encrypted USB drive that held over $200 million worth of Bitcoin. The reason for this is that if you lose access to Bitcoin’s private key, you lose access to the funds. It is thus important to carefully store your private keys, while also keeping it away from prying eyes when dealing with crypto.
- This article was prepared by the BitcoinValleys team using content sourced from BBC